By Chad T. Wilson Law Firm Staff, based on the court’s order in LeBlanc v. Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association (M.D. La.), signed November 2, 2026, and reporting by Mealey’s Insurance Bad Faith, November 11, 2026. Read the original order here.
If your insurance company failed while your claim was still open, a new Louisiana court decision is worth understanding. A federal judge in Baton Rouge took up the question of LIGA bad faith penalties and ruled that the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association cannot be charged the usual insurer bad faith penalties for delays in handling claims it inherits after a carrier goes insolvent. The ruling is narrow, it is not the last word in the case, and it does not erase your right to be paid what your policy owes. It does change how these claims should be argued.
When a Louisiana property insurer becomes insolvent, it stops paying claims. To keep policyholders from being left with nothing, state law created the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association, known as LIGA. It steps in to handle certain “covered claims” of the failed carrier, up to statutory limits. Many Louisiana homeowners met LIGA this way after the wave of insurer failures that followed recent hurricane seasons.
That is the backdrop of this case. The homeowners’ property was damaged by Hurricane Ida in 2021. Their insurer at the time, Southern Fidelity Insurance Company, later became insolvent and entered receivership while the claim was still open. LIGA then took over the file. The homeowners went to court arguing, among other things, that LIGA should face bad faith penalties for how slowly the claim moved after the handoff.
Chief Judge Shelly D. Dick denied the homeowners’ motion for partial summary judgment on the penalty question. In plain terms, the court said the homeowners could not pursue insurer-style bad faith penalties against LIGA for its own post-insolvency claim handling.
The reasoning rests on a few points in Louisiana’s guaranty-association law. LIGA is an association created by statute, not an insurance company, so the court held the penalty statutes written for insurers do not reach it the same way. LIGA’s job is limited to paying “covered claims,” and the definition of a covered claim excludes penalties. And a separate statute, La. R.S. 22:2067, broadly protects LIGA from liability for actions it takes in carrying out its statutory duties. Taken together, the court concluded the homeowners were precluded as a matter of law from recovering bad faith penalties against LIGA under the state’s main bad faith provisions.
Two cautions matter here. First, the order is interlocutory. It denies one motion and narrows the available remedies. It does not end the entire case, and the homeowners’ claim for the benefits actually owed under the policy is a separate question from the penalty theory. Second, this is a single federal district court applying Louisiana law. It is persuasive, not a ruling from Louisiana’s appellate courts, and another judge could see parts of it differently.
For most Louisiana homeowners, the practical point is simple. If a failed carrier left your claim in LIGA’s hands, the path to recovery is not the same as a fight with a solvent insurer. The familiar pressure points, the penalties that encourage a company to pay promptly and in good faith, may not apply to LIGA in the same way. That makes the underlying proof of your loss, the valuation, and the statutory limits and offsets more important, not less.
It also means these files reward early, careful review. Who the proper defendants are, what caps and exclusions apply, whether there are claims against parties other than LIGA, and how the covered-claim rules shape your recovery are all questions worth sorting out at the start rather than at trial.
Whether a solvent carrier or a guaranty association is holding your file, a few steps protect your position:
Insurance companies have an army of lawyers, adjusters, and agents. Policyholders should not have to face a denied, delayed, or underpaid claim alone, and the rules get more complicated when a carrier fails and a guaranty association steps in. Chad T. Wilson Law Firm has resolved more than 6,000 property insurance claims, and we represent policyholders, not insurers. From our headquarters in Webster, Texas, we handle bad faith claims and work with homeowners and business owners nationwide to pursue what their policies actually owe. If you want a straight read on where your claim stands, our team can help you weigh your options. We can’t stop a storm, but we can stand between you and a company that is not paying what it should. The call is free, and we work on contingency, which means no recovery, no fee. Denied, delayed, or underpaid? Call (833) 942-0678 or reach out to an insurance claim lawyer on our team.
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Court rulings described here may be appealed or revisited, allegations referenced are not proven in court, and no outcome is guaranteed. Every claim depends on its own facts and policy language. For advice about your situation, speak with a licensed attorney.
Sources: LeBlanc v. Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association, No. 25-619-SDD-SDJ (M.D. La.), order on partial summary judgment; Mealey’s Insurance Bad Faith, “Summary Judgment Denied In Homeowners’ Hurricane Damage Dispute With LIGA,” November 11, 2026.